Entries Tagged as ''

Supreme Court denies review of COPA decision

Today, the Supreme Court refused to review the July 2008 appellate court decision that ruled the Child Online Protection Act (COPA) unconstitutional.  The law would have barred publication of a wide range of materials on the Internet that met the law’s definition of “harmful to minors,” or required sites to use age verification and other methods to identify users of websites.  Both the district court and appellate court agreed that the voluntary use of filtering software by parents was a less restrictive method of achieving the government’s goal of protecting children from exposure to sexually explicit or adult themed material.

The Justices’ action came without comment and with no noted dissents in Mukasey v. American Civil Liberties Union, et al. (08-565). (h/t to the SCOTUS blog)  The order can be found on the Supreme Court’s website; the order is on page 10, under the heading “Certiorari Denied.”

“We’re delighted that the Supreme Court has upheld the Third Circuit Court of Appeals’ opinion striking down the law,” said Judith Krug, Director of the Office for Intellectual Freedom. “COPA would have restricted access to a vast amount of Constitutionally protected material on the Internet, in violation of the First Amendment. We agree with District Court Judge Lowell Reed, who observed that, ‘perhaps we do the minors of this country harm if First Amendment protections, which they will with age inherit fully, are chipped away in the name of their protection.’”

The order concludes over ten years of litigation.  The law was never enforced.  The Freedom to Read Foundation filed numerous amicus curiae briefs in the case, arguing in favor of First Amendment freedoms.

The New York Times has full details.

Author Scott Turow to headline Freedom to Read Foundation gala

Award-winning author Scott Turow will be the featured speaker at the Freedom to Read Foundation’s (FTRF) 40th anniversary gala celebration, Sunday, July 12, at the new Modern Wing of the Art Institute of Chicago. The event, which will honor FTRF’s visionary founder and executive director Judith Krug and the educational work of Chicago’s McCormick Freedom Museum, will feature a dinner and a gala celebration that will include a gallery viewing of the Renzo Piano-designed museum space. The event is being held in conjunction with the American Library Association’s annual conference and will also feature a special address by legendary author Judy Blume.

Scott Turow

Turow is the author of seven best-selling novels, including “Presumed Innocent,” “The Burden of Proof” and “Personal Injuries.” His non-fiction works include “One L,” about his experiences as a first-year law student (a text that is still being used in law schools), and “Ultimate Punishment,” a reflection on the death penalty that garnered Turow the 2004 Robert F. Kennedy Book Award. He continues to practice as an attorney and as a partner in the Chicago office of Sonnenschein, Nath & Rosenthal, a national law firm that has litigated numerous First Amendment cases.

Blume, whose children’s and young adult books are among the most frequently challenged and banned books in the country, is the author of “Are You There, God? It’s Me, Margaret,” “Blubber,” “Forever” and many other timeless works.

“We are delighted to have Scott Turow participate in this celebration of the Freedom To Read Foundation’s four decades of critical First Amendment work,” said Freedom to Read Foundation president Judith Platt. “As a lawyer and an author, Mr. Turow has a particularly keen appreciation for the dangers of censorship and the value of free expression that are at the heart of the Foundation’s work. We welcome Judy Blume with equal excitement. Her books, which continue to touch and enlighten young people, and her passionate defense of their right to read, have made Judy Blume a true hero for everyone who cares about intellectual freedom.”

Krug, who also has served as director of the ALA’s Office for Intellectual Freedom since its founding in 1967, will be honored additionally at the gala with the William J. Brennan Award of the Thomas Jefferson Center for the Protection of Free Expression. The Brennan Award recognizes a person or group who has demonstrated a commitment to the principles of free expression consistent with the late U.S. Supreme Court Justice’s abiding devotion. In 2005, Krug received an honorary doctorate, Doctor of Humane Letters, from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.

The 40th Anniversary Gala is co-chaired by FTRF trustees Robert P. Doyle and Burton Joseph, both of Chicago. Tickets are $125 and are on sale by calling (800) 545-2433, ext. 4226. Tickets also can be purchased via ALA’s annual conference registration website.

The Freedom to Read Foundation, a sister organization of the American Library Association, was founded in 1969 to promote and defend the right of individuals to freely express ideas and to access information in libraries and elsewhere. FTRF fulfills its mission through the disbursement of grants to individuals and groups, primarily for the purpose of aiding them in litigation, and through direct participation in litigation dealing with freedom of speech and of the press. Its litigation history includes landmark cases that have kept books on library and school shelves; lawsuits challenging portions of the Patriot Act; and the successful Supreme Court challenge to parts of the Communications Decency Act.

The McCormick Freedom Museum inspires generations to better understand, value and protect freedom. Through interactive exploration, visitors gain a greater understanding of the struggle for freedom in the United States and the role the First Amendment plays in society.

More information on the gala and the Freedom to Read Foundation can be found at www.ftrf.org.

Code of Ethics 70th Anniversary Celebration at Midwinter

Rushworth M. Kidder

Rushworth M. Kidder

The Committee on Professional Ethics is pleased to invite you to the 70th anniversary celebration of the ALA Code of Ethics! ALA adopted its first official code of ethics in 1939 and has remained committed to making the ethical principals that guide library work known to the profession and to the general public. This celebration will feature a keynote speech by prominent author Rushworth M. Kidder and also will launch ALA’s new ethics education initiative. Please join us for this very special event — featuring cake, punch, and a toast by ALA President Jim Rettig!

Sunday, January 25, 2009

1:30 – 3:30 p.m.

American Library Association Midwinter Meeting, Denver, Colorado

Colorado Convention Center, Room 207

For more information, please see events pages on the ALA website, the Midwinter Wiki, and Facebook. Contact Angela Maycock at amaycock@ala.org or 800-545-2433 x4221 with any questions.

Lawyers for Libraries/LA date changed to February 27

The date for next month’s “Lawyers for Libraries” Training Institute in Los Angeles has been moved to February 27, 2009. The previously announced date was February 20.

To register for the Lawyers for Libraries training, or for additional information, visit www.ala.org/lawyers or contact Jonathan Kelley at (800) 545-2433 x4226 or jokelley@ala.org. The cost to attend is $395 for one and $745 for two people attending together (e.g. an attorney with his or her library director).

The Lawyers for Libraries Institute is primarily intended to equip attorneys with tools they need to effectively defend the First Amendment in libraries. Participants will be instructed by practicing attorneys specializing in First Amendment law and will be eligible for continuing legal education (CLE) credits for their participation.

Among the topics to be covered during the institute are:

  • Privacy, law enforcement requests for records, and the USA PATRIOT Act
  • Public forum analysis and libraries, including developing meeting room and display case policies
  • Internet filtering and the ongoing repercussions of the Supreme Court’s CIPA decision
  • How to respond to attempts to censor books and other library materials

In addition, a panel of librarians will discuss their real-world experiences with creating and enforcing library policies.

Lawyers for Libraries workshops are open to licensed, practicing attorneys retained to represent or advise libraries on legal issues. Library trustees or board members who are responsible for establishing library policy may also attend. Librarians may attend if they are accompanied by a library attorney.
The training is from 9 a.m. – 5 p.m. at the Westin Los Angeles Airport, 5400 West Century Blvd. Lodging is available at the hotel at just $139 per night.

  • To reserve by phone, call (310) 216-5858 and reserve using group code: Lawyers for Libraries.
  • To reserve online, go to ALA’s special online room reservation page.

The discounted rate is good for stays three days prior to and three days after the institute. Reservations must be made by February 5, 2009, to receive the discounted rate.